TikTok and Instagram are two of the biggest platforms for growing your brand. Both give you strong tools to connect with audiences and boost sales. So when you’re deciding on TikTok vs Instagram, the key is choosing the platform that aligns best with your goals, audience, and content style.
This guide breaks down their strengths in demographics, content format, ads, and more, helping you decide where to focus your efforts.
Let’s delve into it right now!
Drive More Sales for Your Online Store
With LitCommerce’s Feed Management Tool, you can easily create custom feeds in multiple formats (CSV, RSS, TXT, and more) to sync your products directly to TikTok and Instagram. Boost visibility and grow your sales hassle-free.
TikTok vs Instagram: What are Differences?
When it comes to TikTok vs Instagram, each has its own distinctive features and functionalities tailored to different needs. Instagram focuses more on visual storytelling and community, while TikTok emphasizes entertaining viral videos.
1. Demographics
TikTok vs Instagram users show clear demographic differences.
TikTok has experienced explosive growth in popularity over the past few years, particularly among younger users. The platform boasts over 1.88 billion users worldwide, with about 38.5% aged 18–24 and another 30% aged 25–34, showing its strong appeal among both Gen Z and millennials.
Regionally, TikTok is highly popular in multiple regions, including the US, accounting for the largest share of visits (24.19%), followed by Brazil, Indonesia, Vietnam, and Mexico.
These figures highlight TikTok’s broad reach among young adults, its mobile-first nature, and its strong presence not only in the US but also in rapidly growing emerging markets.
Instagram has been around for much longer and has a more diverse user base. According to Statista, the platform has over 1.63 billion active users worldwide across various age groups. Its largest segment falls within the 25–34 range (31.6%), though it also remains highly popular with younger users, with 29.5% of its audience aged 18–24.
Like TikTok, Instagram is also popular worldwide, with the United States being the largest market. However, the platform is also popular in Europe, Latin America, and Asia.
Key takeaways
TikTok skews younger (18-34) and trend-driven, with global growth in emerging markets, while Instagram offers a broader, slightly older (24-35) demographic reach with strong global adoption.
2. Content formats and styles
When comparing TikTok vs Instagram, both platforms offer unique content formats and styles that cater to different audiences and purposes.
TikTok is known for its short-form videos that typically range from 15 to over 60 seconds, but short, highly engaging clips tend to perform best. Here are some of the main features of TikTok content:
- Video length: TikTok videos are short-form, typically ranging from 15 to 60 seconds.
- Video orientation: TikTok videos are primarily vertical.
- Editing features: TikTok offers a wide range of editing tools and effects, including filters, music, text, and transitions.
- Content style: TikTok content often focuses on humor, dance, challenges, lip-syncing, and unboxing.
- Audience engagement: TikTok has a highly engaged and interactive community, with features like duets, reactions, and comments.
Instagram allows for longer videos up to 60 minutes (IGTV), but most videos are 1 minute or less. Here are some of the main features of Instagram content:
- Video length: Instagram allows for longer videos up to 60 minutes (IGTV), but most videos are 1 minute or less.
- Video orientation: Instagram supports both vertical and horizontal videos.
- Editing features: Instagram has more limited editing options compared to TikTok. For this reason, many brands or influencers choose to create social media videos for Instagram outside of the app, via dedicated editing software.
- Content style: Instagram content can be more varied, including photos, videos, stories, reels, and IGTV.
- Audience engagement: Instagram offers a range of engagement options, such as likes, comments, shares, and direct messages.
By understanding the unique features of TikTok and Instagram content, you can create more effective and engaging content on both platforms. It also helps you decide if it is better to use TikTok or Instagram for business.
Key takeaways:
3. Algorithm and reach
The third difference in the TikTok vs Instagram comparison is their algorithms and reach.
TikTok’s For You Page algorithm holds the key to personalized discovery. The algorithm prioritizes content relevance over user popularity, making it possible for new creators to be discovered.
It analyzes a user’s interactions, including likes, shares, comments, and watch time, as well as video details like captions, hashtags, and sounds. Based on this, it shows a personalized feed of videos designed to keep people engaged. This focus on organic reach is why TikTok is so popular for both creators and businesses.
Instagram has evolved from a chronological to a personalized feed. Its algorithm highlights posts from accounts you interact with most, like friends, family, or favorite creators, putting more weight on close relationships.
Engagement metrics such as likes, comments, saves, and shares influence content distribution, alongside recency and content type (photos, videos, Reels). Instagram’s Explore and Reels sections extend content reach beyond followers, but overall, reach is more dependent on an established follower base compared to TikTok’s more open discovery system.
Key takeaways
TikTok’s algorithm is very effective at predicting what content users will engage with based on their interests. Instagram also has a strong algorithm, but reach depends more on follower count.
4. Engagement and interaction
TikTok vs Instagram both offer unique opportunities for engagement and interaction with their respective communities. TikTok’s short video format makes it very shareable and likely to gain wider viral reach than individual Instagram posts. This platform has a higher average video engagement rate (7.4%) than Instagram Reels (4.3%).
TikTok thrives on interaction through comments, duets, and stitches, and in creative ways, users engage. Brands can foster this by prompting challenges/UGC or collaborating with influencers. Responding to comments under strategic hashtags boosts visibility in the engaged community.
Instagram provides many engagement avenues like comments, likes, DMs, polls, and questions. Meaningful interactions – answering messages, showcasing fans, hosting Q&As – cultivate loyalty. As the algorithm elevates highly engaging material, brands should craft conversation-inspiring content.
Key takeaways
TikTok drives viral reach through short, shareable videos and interactive features like duets, stitches, and challenges. Instagram, on the other hand, builds loyalty with comments, DMs, polls, and Q&As, making it stronger for cultivating long-term community engagement.
5. Social commerce features
Both TikTok and Instagram offer powerful features for businesses to engage customers and drive sales online through their shopping features like TikTok Shop and Instagram Shop.
In the TikTok vs Instagram debate, you may ask, “Why is Instagram better than TikTok?” or Why choose TikTok over Instagram? It all depends on your business type.
TikTok offers powerful live streaming and eCommerce capabilities through features like:
- TikTok Shop: Allows businesses to tag products and link to online stores for shopping directly on TikTok videos and livestreams.
- TikTok Business Center: Serves as a centralized hub where businesses can manage multiple ad accounts, collaborate with team members by assigning specific roles and permissions, and oversee campaigns in one dashboard.
- TikTok Ads Manager: Provides advanced features for creating and managing ad campaigns, including options for A/B testing, budget control, and scheduling to maximize reach and ROI.
- Live streaming: Businesses can go live to interact with customers and promote new products/services in real time.
- Metrics: TikTok provides metrics like views, likes, and comments to help businesses analyze engagement and return on ad spend.
Instagram enables businesses to create and promote various types of branded content through Reels and Instagram insights.
- Reels: Similar to TikTok, reels allow businesses to create short-form entertaining videos to engage customers. As mentioned on Instagram, different parts of Instagram, like Feed, Explore, and Reels, each have their own algorithms.
- Instagram Shopping: Enables tagging and selling products directly within posts, Stories, and Reels, allowing customers to browse and purchase without leaving the app.
- Branded content tool: Allow creators and brands to disclose partnerships transparently and access performance data for sponsored posts. The platform’s advertising options, managed via Meta Ads Manager, support targeted campaigns with flexible budgeting and multiple ad formats.
- Analytics: Instagram Insights provides metrics on reach, engagement, and followers to help businesses optimize performance.
Key takeaways
For new businesses, Instagram streamlines reaching audiences and driving sales. Its mature tools require less optimization. Growing companies could later leverage TikTok’s massive user base once comfortable with video content and strategy.
Want to dive deeper into Instagram strategies? Explore our Instagram for business guide packed with practical tips and examples.
Turn Your Instagram Post Into Sales
You’re selling on Shopify, BigCommerce, and want to promote products on Instagram? With LitCommerce’s product feed tool, you can easily promote and sync your products on Instagram, driving more visibility and conversions.
6. Influencer marketing
Both TikTok and Instagram offer unique opportunities for influencer marketing, each with its own strengths and strategies.
Influencer collaborations on TikTok have proven to be highly effective, with many brands seeing significant increases in engagement and reach. The types of content that perform well with influencers on TikTok include challenges, dances, and comedic skits.
TikTok offers several unique opportunities for influencer marketing:
- Hashtags: Leverage trending TikTok hashtags to find relevant influencers and audiences. Brands can use tools such as the Creator Fund, which connects brands with relevant creators, or influencer marketing platforms like AspireIQ and Upfluence.
- Live streams: Influencers can live stream product demos or Q&As to deepen engagement. Businesses can sponsor streams.
- Branded effects: Partner with top creators to develop viral effects and challenges that spread organically.
- Short videos: Influencers can seamlessly integrate products into entertaining videos in their style. Videos are shareable.
- Review channels: TikTok’s growing “Keep it 100” and review communities present marketing opportunities. Creators can honestly review products, building trust with audiences.
- Shopping cart: The cart allows influencers to earn affiliate commissions. Businesses benefit from influencers advertising products right on the app, through to purchase.
TikTok’s features provide influencers with new ways to authentically partner with brands while businesses gain innovative advertising and potential sales channels.
Meanwhile, Instagram offers versatile formats for influencer partnerships:
- Sponsored posts: Influencers can be paid to create traditional sponsored posts promoting brands to their engaged followers.
- Stories: Products can be featured in influencer Stories through links, mentions, or visuals. Stories drive high engagement.
- IGTV videos: Influencers make longer branded videos for IGTV, giving more space to review products or services in-depth.
- Polls and questions: Brand collaborations using these features foster higher follower participation and interaction.
- Live videos: Similar to Instagram Stories, live videos allow real-time product demonstrations and Q&As with followers.
- Collabs: Influencers working together amplify reach by creating joint Reels for higher follower counts.
In the TikTok vs Instagram influencers comparison, Instagram stands out with its diverse content formats, providing flexible solutions for influencer marketing campaigns tailored to business goals and creator styles. Ongoing tests of new tools like affiliate programs may further expand opportunities.
Key takeaways
TikTok is best for viral, authentic, and interactive influencer content that boosts engagement and sales, while Instagram offers versatile formats and affiliate tools to drive polished, branded campaigns and conversions.
7. Content creation
Instagram vs TikTok: Which is better for content creation? Both offer distinct content creation experiences, each with unique strengths.
TikTok primarily focuses on short-form vertical videos. It provides extensive in-app editing features, effects, and soundtracks for content creation. Moreover, its highly viral, algorithm-driven “For You Page” promotes raw, authentic, and casual content styles, encouraging creators to engage with trends, humor, challenges, and music.
Additionally, TikTok’s interactive features, such as duets, stitches, and virtual gifting, foster community engagement and collaborative content creation.
Instagram supports a wider variety of content formats, including photos, longer videos (up to 60 minutes on IGTV), Reels (which are similar to TikTok’s short videos), Stories, and carousel posts. It tends to prioritize polished, visually aesthetic content that is well-suited for brand building and storytelling.
Furthermore, while Instagram provides tools for saving collections and highlights, its native editing tools are generally less extensive compared to TikTok. In terms of engagement, Instagram offers features like polls, questions in Stories, and group messaging, which encourage interaction within the app in different ways.
Key takeaways
TikTok excels in short, engaging, and authentic videos with advanced editing tools and a viral algorithm that promotes trends and interaction. In contrast, Instagram offers a wider variety of polished and diverse content formats ideal for brand storytelling and longer engagement.
8. Advertising options
When evaluating TikTok vs Instagram, many businesses wonder: Is TikTok better than Instagram for advertising? Both platforms allow advertising and organic posting.
TikTok’s advertising platform, TikTok Ads Manager, offers a range of ad formats, including Branded Effects, In-Feed Ads, and Hashtag Challenges.
- In-feed ads appear in users’ feeds, while Branded Effects allow brands to create custom filters and effects for users to apply to their videos.
- Hashtag challenges encourage user-generated content and can be a highly effective way to increase engagement.
Besides, TikTok offers a wide range of targeting options, including age, gender, location, interests, and devices. Budgeting strategies include options for daily or lifetime budgets, with bidding options for cost-per-click or cost-per-impression.
Compared to TikTok, Instagram’s advertising platform through Facebook Ad Manager offers various ad formats, including Video Ads, Carousel Ads, Photo Ads, Stories Ads, and Explore Ads.
- Photo Ads and Video Ads appear in users’ feeds, while Carousel Ads allow users to swipe through multiple images or videos.
- Stories Ads appear in users’ Stories, while Explore Ads are shown to users browsing the Explore page.
Instagram’s targeting options include demographics, interests, behaviors, and custom audiences based on data from a business’s website or app. Budgeting strategies include options for daily budgets or lifetime budgets, with bidding options for cost-per-click or cost-per-impression. spiring content.
Key takeaways
Both TikTok and Instagram support paid advertising and organic posting, with flexible budgeting and bidding options. Instagram ads are more videos, Stories ads, and Shopping ads, while TikTok focuses more on in-feed and TopView ads.
9. Analytics
The last factor in the TikTok vs Instagram comparison is analytics.
Metrics to monitor TikTok include views, likes, shares, comments, and engagement rates. Tracking key metrics provides insights into what content resonates most with an audience, allowing businesses to refine their strategies accordingly.
Platforms like TikTok’s analytics dashboard and third-party tools like HypeAuditor, FastMoss, etc, to help track TikTok’s performance.
Turning to Instagram, some key metrics to track on Instagram for insight are reach, impressions, engagement rate, and click-through rate. Monitoring these provides a well-rounded view of audience interaction and content performance.
Besides, Instagram Insights, the platform’s built-in analytics tool, provides businesses with valuable metrics to understand audience engagement and identify ways to improve. Key metrics shed light on demographics’ top-performing content and help businesses better understand their audience.
Key takeaways
TikTok’s metrics may be more geared toward video performance, while Instagram focuses more on followers and engagement.
The Verdict
- TikTok is best for trend-driven businesses like fashion, beauty, lifestyle, and entertainment looking to go viral with short, authentic videos. Great for building brand awareness quickly and engaging younger, highly active audiences.
- Instagram is best for businesses that rely on polished visuals, such as food, home goods, travel, and art. Ideal for storytelling, brand building, and long-term customer loyalty through diverse content formats.
TikTok vs Instagram – FAQs
- Is TikTok better than Instagram?
Both TikTok and Instagram have their own unique features and audiences. TikTok is suitable for businesses targeting a younger audience and can create engaging short-form videos. On the other hand, Instagram is ideal for showcasing products or services visually and engaging with the audience through influencer marketing and user-generated content.
- Do people prefer Instagram or TikTok?
People’s preferences between Instagram and TikTok vary depending on their age and interests. While Instagram has a wider age range of users, TikTok is more popular among younger audiences, with most users under 30 years old. Additionally, TikTok is preferred by some for its creative and entertaining content, while others favor Instagram for its photo-sharing features and blog-like posts.
- Why do people use TikTok over Instagram?
According to Social Media Today, TikTok is preferred over Instagram as it allows users to express themselves more authentically, with an average of 53% of TikTok users trusting others to be their real selves on the platform. In contrast, TikTok’s emphasis on short, entertaining videos and its algorithms have made the platform appealing by allowing users to freely express themselves without pressure to project perfection. Instagram can sometimes have the opposite effect on self-perception with its focus on polished images.
- Is it easier to go viral on Instagram or TikTok?
Both Instagram and TikTok have the potential for content to go viral, but the factors contributing to virality may differ between the two platforms. Instagram has a wider audience range, while TikTok’s algorithm promotes content based on user interests and engagement, making it easier for accounts with a smaller following to potentially go viral.
TikTok vs Instagram for Business: Which One Suits You Most
In conclusion, choosing between Instagram vs TikTok for business depends on various factors, including target audience, marketing goals, and content type.
If you would like additional details or recommendations on this topic, please feel free to contact us. We also encourage you to check out our Retailer Blog, where LitCommerce regularly shares informative perspectives on the constantly changing landscape of eCommerce.
